Key Highlights

  • Shares rose 1.62% to USD 104.37 on relative Volume of 1.92.
  • Third-quarter Net Income was USD 128.7 million versus USD 115.3 million.
  • The combined ratio improved to 96.8% from 98.6%.
  • The board authorized a new repurchase program of up to USD 200 million.

Selective Insurance Group (NASDAQ:SIGI) shares traded at USD 104.37 on November 20, 2026, up 1.62%, with a relative volume at time of 1.92. The company has given no reason for the heavy trading. It announced a new repurchase program on October 22, then filed its Quarterly Report and held its Earnings Call on October 23, so those events predate the session.

Selective Insurance Group is a New Jersey corporation based at 40 Wantage Avenue in Branchville. Through its insurance subsidiaries it reports four segments: Standard Commercial Lines, Standard Personal Lines, E&S Lines and Investments. Insurance segments are judged on underwriting income, Return on Equity contribution and combined ratios, and Investments on after-tax net Investment income. The company reports on a calendar year ending December 31.

The Third Quarter

Net premiums earned were USD 1.18 billion versus USD 1.20 billion, and total revenues were USD 1.33 billion versus USD 1.36 billion. Net investment income was USD 160.5 million versus USD 138.7 million, while net realized and unrealized investment losses were USD 19.4 million versus gains of USD 8.1 million.

Loss and loss expense incurred was USD 762.7 million versus USD 819.0 million, and total expenses were USD 1.16 billion versus USD 1.21 billion. Income before tax was USD 162.1 million versus USD 145.7 million. Net income was USD 128.7 million versus USD 115.3 million, and income available to common stockholders was USD 126.4 million, or USD 2.11 per diluted share, versus USD 113.0 million, or USD 1.85.

Non-GAAP Operating Income was USD 141.7 million, or USD 2.37 per diluted share, versus USD 106.7 million, or USD 1.75. The combined ratio of 96.8% was 1.8 points better than a year earlier, with no prior-year casualty reserve development in any segment. Net catastrophe losses in the insurance segments were USD 64.1 million.

Nine Months

Net premiums earned were USD 3.61 billion versus USD 3.55 billion, and total revenues were USD 4.07 billion versus USD 3.97 billion. Net income was USD 355.7 million versus USD 311.2 million, and income available to common stockholders was USD 348.8 million, or USD 5.80 per diluted share, versus USD 304.3 million, or USD 4.97. The combined ratio was 97.7% versus 98.3%. Dividends declared were USD 0.43 per common share for the quarter and USD 1.29 for nine months.

Balance Sheet and Capital

Total Assets were USD 15.71 billion versus USD 15.16 billion at December 31, 2025. Total investments were USD 11.49 billion and long-term Debt was USD 901.5 million. Equity was USD 3.45 billion versus USD 3.61 billion, and accumulated other comprehensive loss was USD 491.8 million versus USD 151.7 million.

Operating activities provided USD 817.7 million over nine months versus USD 856.8 million. The company repurchased 1,300,663 shares for USD 116.9 million. The new program of up to USD 200 million, authorized on October 22, lifts total repurchase capacity to USD 253.1 million.

2026 Guidance

On the call, management said it still expects a GAAP combined ratio of 96.5% to 97.5% for the year, assuming 5.5 points of catastrophe losses, down from six points a quarter earlier. It raised expected after-tax net investment income to USD 490 million from USD 480 million.

The guidance assumes an effective tax rate of 21.5% and a fully diluted weighted average share count of 59.9 million, reflecting repurchases so far this year. Management also still expects a full-year underwriting expense ratio of about 31.5%.

What to Watch Next for Selective

The company has given no reason for the November 20 trading, and its results, buyback and guidance came earlier. The reported record shows higher profit, a better combined ratio and a lower equity base after unrealized losses. The remaining repurchase capacity is the point to follow.