Key Highlights

  • Ally Financial (NYSE:ALLY) lifted adjusted EPS 16% to USD 1.34 and boosted its Dividend to USD 0.35, yet its shares sit roughly 4.3% above the 52-week low.
  • XP Inc raised adjusted EPS 9% to BRL 2.69 and unveiled a BRL 1.5 billion buyback, although Return on Equity dipped to 21.7%.
  • Piper Sandler's advisory Revenue climbed 18% to USD 250.3 million, but adjusted EPS of USD 0.87 came in under the roughly USD 0.93 expected.
  • Financials were the laggards on November 17 with a near 2% slide, while the 10-year Treasury Yield hovered around 5.1%.

1. Ally Financial (NYSE:ALLY)

Ally Financial (NYSE:ALLY) owns the most durable Earnings of the three. Adjusted EPS for the third quarter rose 16% to USD 1.34, GAAP EPS advanced 10% to USD 1.30, and the core return on tangible common equity came to 13.1%. Net interest Margin stood at 3.62%, 11 basis points above a year earlier, as funding costs eased, and interest paid on deposits fell to USD 1.21 billion from USD 1.30 billion. Lending Demand is robust. Consumer auto originations increased 10% to USD 12.9 billion on a record 4.8 million applications, and noninterest expense held flat. The common equity tier 1 ratio improved to 10.2%, and the quarterly payout was lifted to USD 0.35 from USD 0.30, equal to a yield near 3.7%. Credit requires monitoring. The retail auto net charge off rate reached 1.89%, delinquencies beyond 30 days were 4.96%, and the Loan loss provision climbed to USD 529 million from USD 415 million, which management linked to higher early delinquencies on recent loans. The Balance Sheet is modestly asset sensitive, and October rating downgrades pointed to rate risk. Shares dropped 1.71% to USD 37.46 on November 17, with an RSI of 42.7. Ally ranks first because its earnings are expanding on recurring lending income, and steady monthly credit data would back a recovery.

2. XP Inc (NASDAQ:XP)

XP Inc (NASDAQ:XP) takes second place, with high returns that are beginning to ease. This Brazilian Investment platform reported Q3 gross revenue growth of 8%, reaching BRL 5.3 billion, while adjusted Net Income grew 4% to BRL 1.38 billion and adjusted diluted EPS rose 9% to BRL 2.69 thanks to fewer shares outstanding. Total client Assets hit BRL 1.57 trillion, up 11%, and the loan portfolio expanded 28% to BRL 86.2 billion. Returns are sliding. Adjusted return on average equity slipped to 21.7% from 23.0%, net inflows dropped 26% to BRL 22 billion, active clients rose just 1% and costs grew faster than revenue. A strong dollar and U.S. long term yields near 5.4% have also weighed on Brazilian assets. Capital return offers the clearest support. The firm announced a BRL 1.5 billion buyback and BRL 1.3 billion of dividends, and it is retiring about 11.7 million treasury shares, roughly 2.3% of the total. A capital ratio of 20.3% leaves considerable room for growth, while credit and insurance diversify income beyond trading. Shares fell 1.69% to USD 14.58 on November 17, about 6% above their 52-week low. XP ranks second because earnings continue to grow, but a rebound in inflows or lower Brazilian rates is required to restore its premium valuation.

3. Piper Sandler (NYSE:PIPR)

Piper Sandler (NYSE:PIPR) is third because its earnings are the most exposed to interest rates. Adjusted net revenues for the third quarter were level at USD 456.0 million, and adjusted EPS of USD 0.87 dropped 9%, falling short of roughly USD 0.93 expected. The revenue mix diverged sharply. Advisory services revenue increased 18% to USD 250.3 million, corporate Investment Banking posted a record third quarter near USD 307 million, and fixed income revenue was the strongest since 2021. Corporate financing income, however, declined 29% as the firm priced 16 equity deals versus 23 a year earlier, and municipal financing fell 36% since higher rates prompted issuers to delay. The adjusted Operating Margin narrowed to 19.8% from 21.2%. Before the report shares were near USD 68.72; they slid to around USD 63.77 in subsequent days and ended November 17 at USD 65.03, approximately 6% over the 52-week trough. Management also has a fresh USD 200 million repurchase approval valid through 2028, along with a USD 0.20 quarterly payout due December 11. Nine month GAAP net revenues advanced 15%. Piper Sandler ranks third because advisory momentum is genuine, yet municipal and equity issuance requires lower or steadier rates to recover, and markets are assigning a high probability to another Federal Reserve increase in December.

Where Things Stand

Of the top 3 financial stocks near 52-week lows, Ally Financial has the most durable earnings, with adjusted EPS up 16% and a higher dividend. XP Inc continues to grow EPS but needs stronger inflows, while Piper Sandler's advisory growth is offset by rate sensitive financing businesses. Steadier Treasury yields would help all three.