Key Highlights

  • At 1,691.17%, Primis Financial posts the steepest trailing increase in per-share earnings within the group, though prior-year losses and non-recurring gains inflate that figure.
  • For the second quarter, Carter Bankshares booked reported net income of USD 28.9 million, while its adjusted figure came to USD 11.6 million.
  • Among the eight lenders, ACNB recorded the broadest net interest margin in the second quarter, at 4.56%.
  • By calculation, the USD 12.22 trailing EPS at Tompkins Financial sits at roughly 1.5 times April to June earnings per share of USD 2.04 once annualised.
  • Taken together, the eight lenders carry a market capitalisation near USD 13.03 billion on a calculated basis.

What Lies Beneath the Steepest Trailing EPS Gains Among These Bank Earnings Candidates?

Rapid trailing growth in per-share profit sets these eight lenders apart, and none of them released company-specific news on October 21 that would account for share moves. Shares of Tompkins Financial (NYSE American:TMP) fell 0.48% to USD 98.87, ConnectOne Bancorp (NYSE:CNOB) eased 0.26% to USD 30.87, ACNB (NASDAQ:ACNB) declined 0.22% to USD 63.45 and Primis Financial (NASDAQ:FRST) slipped 0.57% to USD 15.58. Meanwhile, Customers Bancorp (NYSE:CUBI) dipped 0.04% to USD 75.99, First National (NASDAQ:FXNC) lost 0.44% to USD 29.55, Carter Bankshares (NASDAQ:CARE) gained 0.48% to USD 30.33, and Associated Banc-Corp (NYSE:ASB) added 0.40% to USD 29.21.

Four of the group are due on Thursday, October 22: Customers Bancorp, ConnectOne Bancorp, Primis Financial and Associated Banc-Corp, and all of these except ConnectOne Bancorp publish once markets shut. Dates remain unconfirmed for ACNB, Tompkins Financial, Carter Bankshares and First National, which are likely to report in late October or over the following weeks, making the discussion of them preliminary.

Because the growth rates largely mirror prior-year losses, merger expenses or non-recurring gains, the second-quarter run-rate offers a more reliable yardstick. A constructive outcome would feature stable margins and contained credit, free of fresh one-off items. A disappointing one would involve narrowing margins, climbing nonperforming loans or profits that once more depend on gains that will not recur.

Is the 1,691.17% Trailing EPS Jump at Primis Financial a Reliable Earnings Signal?

Primis Financial owns Primis Bank, a Virginia lender. In the second quarter it earned USD 0.38 per share, up from USD 0.10 a year before, a result that benefited from a USD 5.9 million gain on an insurance agency, with the margin at 3.45%. Guidance pointed to a margin that should stay within roughly 1 to 2 basis points around where it currently stands. Credit is the main worry, since a USD 5.3 million specific reserve was set against the biggest office loan. Its P/E of 7.25 is skewed.

Which Earnings Measure Best Captures Carter Bankshares' Run-Rate?

Carter Bankshares, parent of Carter Bank and Trust, operates across Virginia and North Carolina. Second-quarter reported net income came to USD 28.9 million, a total lifted by an insurance gain worth USD 35.9 million and reduced by a securities loss of USD 12.5 million; stripping those out leaves USD 11.6 million, equal to USD 0.53 per share. The margin expanded to 3.38% from 3.07%. As a share of loans, nonperforming loans climbed to 1.01%, compared with 0.64% for the first quarter.

Can Associated Banc-Corp Extend Its Margin Gains Following the American National Deal?

Associated Banc-Corp operates in Texas, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Illinois and Missouri. Adjusted EPS for the second quarter reached USD 0.73, while the margin improved by 14 basis points to 3.17%, and management anticipates further widening in each of the two quarters left in the year. Non-accrual loans increased by USD 39 million to USD 150 million, with American National contributing around half. A repositioning loss in the prior-year period explains the trailing increase of 276.83%.

Will ConnectOne Bancorp Keep Credit Costs in Check After Its Multifamily Write-Off?

ConnectOne Bancorp, based in New Jersey, serves private banking, business and commercial real estate borrowers. It earned USD 0.80 per share in the second quarter, compared with USD 0.72 in the first, and its margin stood at 3.42%. Following a USD 13.8 million charge-off on a multifamily loan, nonperforming assets rose to 0.55% of total assets. A merger loss twelve months earlier underpins the trailing rise of 253.99%.

Is Acquisition Accretion Inflating First National's 4.15% Margin Ahead of Earnings?

First National owns First Bank, a Virginia institution. Its April to June earnings per share reached USD 0.63, up from USD 0.54 in the first quarter, with acquisition accounting accretion contributing roughly five basis points to the margin. Asset quality was sound: nonperforming assets equalled 0.23% of assets. A sale of branches slated for October should generate a non-recurring gain, likely booked in the fourth quarter.

Could Tompkins Financial Deliver a Fourth Consecutive Record in Earnings?

Tompkins Financial, a bank holding company headquartered in New York, runs Tompkins Community Bank alongside trust and insurance operations. At USD 2.04, earnings per share for the April to June period marked a third record in a row, compared with USD 1.50 twelve months before, and the margin was 3.58%. Loans classed as special mention and substandard increased to roughly USD 140 million. The trailing advance of 120.03% stems from a soft 2025 comparison.

How Does the Palantir Tie-Up Bear on Customers Bancorp's Earnings Report?

Customers Bancorp, a Pennsylvania company, owns Customers Bank and runs a digital payments platform that gathers fintech deposits. On October 15 it began working with Palantir (NASDAQ:PLTR) on onboarding deposits. For the April to June quarter, earnings per share of USD 2.05 came in ahead of the USD 1.99 consensus, and management described the 3.17% margin as the likely trough for 2026. In September, Morgan Stanley cut its rating on the stock to Underweight.

Will ACNB Sustain Its 4.56% Margin in Upcoming Earnings?

ACNB, which owns ACNB Bank, is a Pennsylvania company covering Maryland and the south-central part of Pennsylvania. Earnings per share for the April to June period reached USD 1.49, against USD 1.11 in the prior-year period and USD 1.32 in the first quarter, as the margin increased to 4.56%. Nonperforming loans equalled 0.41% of loans. A one-off special distribution is embedded in the 2.52% yield, and non-recurring items also colour the trailing increase of 95.54%.

How Do the Eight Banks Stack Up on Margin, Earnings Run-Rate and P/E?

On a calculated basis, the eight lenders together are worth roughly USD 13.03 billion, of which Associated Banc-Corp represents around 42.4% by calculation. In the second quarter, margins spanned from 4.56% at ACNB down to 3.17% at both Customers Bancorp and Associated Banc-Corp, a gap of 1.39 points by calculation. Quarter on quarter, EPS increased by roughly 16.7% at First National, with ACNB up 12.9% and ConnectOne Bancorp up 11.1%, each figure calculated.

Trailing P/E multiples stretch from 5.22 for Carter Bankshares to 12.32 for First National, a calculated difference of 7.10 points, although most of these readings are skewed. By calculation, the USD 12.22 trailing EPS at Tompkins Financial is about 1.5 times its annualised April to June figure of USD 8.16, while the USD 5.81 at Carter Bankshares is roughly 2.7 times its annualised adjusted figure for that quarter of USD 2.12, again calculated, a gap that signals non-recurring items.

Which Earnings Dates and Benchmarks Will Shape the Trailing Per-Share Growth Story?

ConnectOne Bancorp opens the sequence on Thursday, October 22, and Customers Bancorp, Associated Banc-Corp and Primis Financial release results after markets shut that day; conference calls for Customers Bancorp and Primis Financial follow on October 23. The comparison points are USD 0.38 for Primis Financial, adjusted EPS of USD 0.73 for Associated Banc-Corp and USD 0.80 for ConnectOne Bancorp. Still pending are the reporting dates for First National, ACNB, Carter Bankshares and Tompkins Financial.