A Royal Bank of Canada bank branch in Ottawa. (Credit: Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press files)

As climate-concerned central planners continue to discover, their actions have unintended consequences — some of which work completely contrary to their stated intentions. The latest example: as the result of changes to Canada’s Competition Act that were cheered on last year by environmental organizations like Greenpeace, RBC is now scrapping some of its environmental commitments and disclosures. Last week, the bank, which has Canada’s largest corporate market cap at $237 billion, announced it was “retiring” the “sustainable finance commitment” it made in 2019 and would no longer disclose its energy supply ratio, citing the Competition Act changes as a reason for its decision.

The changes in question require companies to substantiate claims about their environmental performance according to “internationally recognized methodology.” Canada’s largest oilsands companies denounced the policy, writing that the prescribed “internationally recognized methodology” for environmental reporting “may or may not exist,” which “opens the door for frivolous litigation.” Alberta’s Minister of Environment, Rebecca Schulz, called the legislation “an attack on freedom of speech” and the Saskatchewan government called it a “gag law” on oil and gas companies.

David Suzuki wrote in a blog post last year that “the fact that it’s just the fossil fuel industry complaining is telling.” But RBC is not an oil company. As it describes in its annual sustainability report, it believes environmental reporting should be accurate, but “given the nascent nature of climate-related metrics, there are limited and evolving recognized methodologies for claims in these areas. As a result, this limits the information we can share on certain sustainability disclosures and the progress we are making.” In other words, the oilsands companies were right: the government’s prescription that companies’ environmental claims be backed up by “internationally recognized methodology” is impossible because these methodologies are not well defined.

If the activists’ goal in supporting the Competition Act changes was to increase companies’ contribution to fighting global warming and force them to improve their environmental reporting, the latest developments indicate their central planning initiative has backfired. Whether RBC dropping its sustainable finance targets and reducing its external disclosures is a good or bad thing is a separate debate, but the activists certainly did not intend either. While unintended, however, this result was not unpredictable: oilsands companies also reduced their environmental communications last year as a result of the Competition Act changes.

Story Continues

There are other examples of climate-focused central planning producing unintended environmental consequences. For example, National Review reports that in the United States “small, efficient cars are increasingly rare, thanks to overly aggressive fuel-economy standards.” Beginning in 2009, the Obama administration expanded automobile regulation and under its Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) standards, a vehicle’s physical footprint determined its fuel efficiency targets. Since smaller cars were given much more stringent regulatory targets, small efficient cars “became regulatory casualties”: their government-mandated targets were so aggressive “that selling them became impractical.” According to National Review, sedans have shrunk to only about six per cent of sales by major American manufacturers, versus approximately half 20 years ago. Average vehicle size has bloated.

Today’s governmental push toward electric vehicles, both in Canada and the United States, may well have similarly negative effects. Electric cars are much heavier than gasoline cars, which means that even if refuelling electric vehicles has less effect on global warming, they carry greater environmental costs related to manufacturing, road wear and tire wear. As Mark P. Mills explained in a Manhattan Institute study, the energy-intensive mining and processing required to manufacture electric vehicle batteries result in carbon emissions that “substantially offset reductions from avoiding gasoline and, as the demand for battery minerals explodes, the net reductions will shrink, may vanish, and could even lead to a net increase in emissions.”

Matthew Lau: Minimum wages are even more harmful than we thought Matthew Lau: Lessons for Canada in Argentina's newly freed markets

In general, any kind of government regulation, whether environmental or otherwise, that restricts consumer choice or adds to the cost of manufacturing new vehicles will have negative unintended consequences. When governments add cost and inconvenience to the manufacture or sale of new cars, drivers will naturally react by keeping old cars on the road longer, which has negative effects on both the environment and safety. To avoid these negative unintended consequences — in automobiles, financial services, the oilsands or any other industry — the solution is simple. Stop the central planning.

Bookmark our website and support our journalism: Don’t miss the business news you need to know — add financialpost.com to your bookmarks and sign up for our newsletters here.