Quebecor Inc. (TSX:QBR.B) shares rose on Thursday, November 19, recovering part of a steep fall earlier in the week, as the company defended its proposed Takeover of TELUS. The move came the same day a report said BCE had held preliminary talks with TELUS, and Quebecor issued a statement arguing a Bell-TELUS deal would hurt consumers.

The Class B shares closed near $59.55, up about $2.61, in a market that fell sharply.

What happened

BCE, Bell Canada's parent, had held early discussions with TELUS and hired financial and legal advisers as it weighs a response to Quebecor's approach. No BCE offer has been made.

Quebecor responded on Thursday morning. It said a combination of Bell and TELUS "would not represent a positive outcome for consumers" and argued that "Canada needs strong companies that can invest at scale while remaining under Canadian control." It said it looks forward to meeting TELUS management on November 23.

Price data for the day was not entirely consistent. The shares appear to have swung through the session before ending up.

Why it matters

Quebecor, which owns Videotron, Freedom Mobile and Fizz, disclosed its proposal for TELUS on Monday, November 16. It offered $6.35 in cash plus 0.17 of a Quebecor Class B share for each TELUS share, a package it valued at about $19.45, or about $31 billion in all.

Investors did not welcome the bid. Quebecor's Class B shares fell by roughly a seventh on Monday and slipped further on Tuesday. Buyers' shares often fall when they propose large deals, as investors worry about overpaying, taking on Debt and issuing many new shares.

Because most of the offer is in Quebecor stock, that drop also cut the value of the bid. At Thursday's price, the package works out to roughly $16.50 per TELUS share by our calculation.

The bigger picture

The fight now has a possible third player. Analysts said a bidding war could loom, but regulators would need to approve any deal. Desjardins analyst Jerome Dubreuil said approval for a Merger of two Big Three carriers "would likely be a long shot."

TELUS's board has said Quebecor has not explained how its plan would win approval and objected that TELUS shareholders would get a minority of the votes in the combined company.

Thursday was rough for the market overall. The S&P/TSX Composite fell 549.32 points to its lowest close since May, while TELUS shares jumped sharply.

What to watch next

The November 23 meeting between Quebecor and TELUS management is the next key date. Watch for any change in Quebecor's terms, any formal offer from BCE and signals from Ottawa, which has said it will not prejudge a review.

For Quebecor shareholders, the question is whether the company sweetens its bid, walks away or wins over TELUS's board. Any decision to raise the offer could mean more cash, more debt or more new shares, each of which would weigh on how investors value the stock. A clear regulatory path, on the other hand, could ease some of the doubts that hit the shares this week.