Quebecor Inc. shares kept sliding on Tuesday, November 17, as investors grew more doubtful about its surprise $31-billion bid for Telus Corp. The Class B stock (TSX:QBR.B) fell $8.25 to $57.00, the worst showing on the S&P/TSX Composite, a day after it had already lost $11.81.

Analysts spent the day warning that regulators may block the deal or Demand painful concessions, and that Quebecor's Balance Sheet would be stretched if it goes ahead.

What happened

Quebecor made its proposal public on Monday, November 16. It offered Telus shareholders $6.35 in cash plus 0.17 of a Quebecor Class B share for each Telus share. Based on Quebecor's price the previous Friday, it valued the offer at $19.45 per Telus share, against Telus's Friday close of $12.14.

The market reaction was swift. Quebecor's Class B shares closed at $77.06 on Friday, November 13, then dropped to $65.25 on Monday and to $57.00 on Tuesday. That is a two-day loss of about $20 a share, or roughly a quarter of the stock's value.

Telus has not accepted the offer. Its chief executive, Victor Dodig, said the company has "serious concerns" and that the offer "doesn't nearly reflect the value of Telus." Telus has set up a special committee of independent directors to review it.

Why it matters

The core worry is regulation. The deal would bring together two of Canada's four largest wireless carriers, and Quebecor's Freedom Mobile was created as a fourth national player when it was carved out of the Rogers-Shaw merger.

RBC analyst Drew McReynolds sees a "low probability" of the companies combining and said approvals "without material remedies appears to us to be a non-starter." Scotiabank's Maher Yaghi said the deal has a "low chance of going through" if Quebecor will not give up Freedom Mobile. Desjardins analyst Jerome Dubreuil put the odds of closing at about one in four and said: "We like the destination for Quebecor, but the road there looks challenging."

BMO's Tim Casey downgraded Quebecor to market perform from outperform on Monday. He said the deal turns Quebecor into a "multi-year execution and balance sheet repair story." On Quebecor's own assumptions, the combined company's net Debt would be about 4.1 times estimated 2027 Earnings before interest, taxes, Depreciation and amortization.

Ottawa is also watching. Industry Minister Mélanie Joly said the deal will be "rigorously reviewed" by the Competition Bureau and the CRTC.

The bigger picture

Because part of the offer is paid in Quebecor stock, the falling share price shrinks the bid itself. At Tuesday's close of $57.00, the cash and stock package works out to roughly $16 per Telus share, well below the $19.45 headline value.

Quebecor chief executive Pierre Karl Péladeau defended the price. "The market is valuing their shares at $12. It's not me, it's the market," he said. Quebecor says the Merger would save about $160 million a year in operating costs and $235 million a year in Capital spending.

The slide came on a rough day for Canadian stocks. The S&P/TSX Composite fell about 407 points to 35,315.30, its fourth straight loss, with telecoms, technology and banks leading the decline.

What to watch next

Mr. Péladeau and Mr. Dodig are scheduled to meet next Monday, November 23. Investors will look for any sign that Quebecor is willing to sweeten the cash portion, sell Freedom Mobile, or walk away.

Any early signals from the Competition Bureau, the CRTC or Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada will also matter. Until the regulatory path is clearer, Quebecor's share price is likely to trade on the deal's odds rather than on its own telecom and media results.