First Quantum Minerals Ltd. bucked a falling market on Tuesday, November 17, after Panama's government agreed to open formal talks on restarting the shuttered Cobre Panamá copper mine. The stock (TSX:FM) rose $1.09 to $30.90, one of the top gainers on the S&P/TSX Composite.

The move partly reversed a sharp drop on Monday, when the shares closed at $29.81 before the announcement.

What happened

On Monday, November 16, Panamanian President José Raúl Mulino authorized formal negotiations with Minera Panamá, First Quantum's local subsidiary, over a possible restart of the mine. An interministerial team led by Commerce and Industries Minister Julio Moltó will run the talks.

The negotiations will cover jobs, economic benefits, environmental oversight and an end to arbitration claims against Panama. Mulino set out five principles: Panamanian ownership of the mineral resources, maximum economic benefit for the country, national sovereignty, strict environmental protection and respect for the constitution and national laws.

The shares jumped at the open, trading as high as $32.46, before giving back some of the gain as the broader market sold off.

Why it matters

Cobre Panamá is First Quantum's flagship asset. Mining has been halted since November 2023, when Panama's Supreme Court ruled the operating contract unconstitutional after nationwide protests. The mine, about 120 kilometres west of Panama City, produced roughly 331,000 tonnes of copper in 2023.

A restart would be a major turning point. Right now the site is only processing stockpiled ore, which began in the second quarter of 2026 and is expected to Yield 30,000 to 40,000 tonnes of copper this year. Those stockpiles are expected to run out around mid-2027, so a new agreement is needed for any broader restart. Without a deal, output from the site would wind down once that ore is gone.

BMO analyst Matthew Murphy said he sees "the commencement of negotiations as a key and positive step to enable a restart of mining operations." BMO rates the shares outperform with a $60 target.

The bigger picture

The deal will not look like the old one. Any agreement must include a closure plan financed by the company that is orderly, verifiable and definitive, with reforestation. Closure would be mandatory with no option to extend, and the arrangement would not be a mining concession.

Murphy noted that "most of the requirements stated by the President have been named in previous disclosures," and that the no-extension condition was already in a high-level commission report. Not everyone is convinced the upside remains. One analyst cut the stock to hold from buy the same day, arguing a restart appears largely priced in and that a firm closure timeline could cap how much copper is recovered.

The gain stood out on a weak day. The S&P/TSX Composite fell about 407 points to 35,315.30 as banks, technology and telecoms slumped, while copper prices were roughly flat near US$5.995 a pound.

What to watch next

No restart date or operating term has been announced. Investors will watch for the pace of talks, the shape of any closure timeline and how the government handles public consultation with nearby communities, which Mulino said will accompany the negotiations.

The fate of First Quantum's arbitration claims against Panama will also be a key bargaining chip. Even with talks under way, the shares remain far below their 52-week high of $49.27, a sign that many investors still want to see a signed agreement before paying up. For now, the talks give the stock its first clear path forward in years.