Quebecor's unsolicited proposal to buy TELUS (TSX:T) for about $31 billion in cash and stock has turned a long comparison between Canada's two struggling telecom giants into a Takeover story. For TELUS shareholders, the offer puts a value of roughly $19.45 per share on a stock that closed at $12.14 before the news. For BCE (TSX:BCE), a combined Quebecor-TELUS would create a larger national rival. TELUS has raised serious concerns, and any deal would face heavy regulatory review.

Here is how the two incumbents compare after their third-quarter results and what the bid could change.

What has Quebecor proposed?

Quebecor said on November 16 that it had submitted an enhanced, non-binding proposal under which TELUS shareholders would receive $6.35 in cash and 0.17 Quebecor class B shares for each TELUS share. Quebecor valued the offer at about $19.45 per share, roughly a 60% premium. Because most of the payment is in Quebecor shares, the value moves with Quebecor's stock price. Quebecor said its first proposal was sent in June.

Quebecor estimates about $160 million in annual operating savings and $235 million in annual Capital savings, on top of TELUS's own efficiency plan. It promised to keep TELUS brands and the Vancouver headquarters.

How did TELUS respond?

TELUS formed a special committee of independent directors to review the proposal and other alternatives. Chief Executive Victor Dodig said the company has "serious concerns," with regulation the largest hurdle, and that the offer "doesn't nearly reflect the value of Telus." He also said the proposed dual-class share structure, which would give TELUS holders about 54% of the economic interest but about 23% of the votes, "doesn't work."

The federal government said the proposal would be rigorously reviewed by the Competition Bureau and the CRTC. Quebecor shares fell 12.6% to $57 on November 17, extending a two-day drop to about 26%.

How did TELUS perform in the third quarter?

TELUS reported operating revenues and other income of $5.03 billion, down from $5.11 billion, and adjusted EBITDA of $1.8 billion, down 5%. It booked an $800 million non-cash Impairment on TELUS Health, contributing to a net loss of about $660 million. Net Debt to adjusted EBITDA was 3.6 times. The core telecom unit held up better, with 84,000 mobile phone net additions and blended churn of 1.01%, its lowest in three years.

TELUS announced an efficiency program targeting about $900 million of annual cash savings by the end of 2028 and is prioritizing sales of TELUS Health and TELUS Agriculture & Consumer Goods. In July it cut its quarterly Dividend by 55% to $0.1875 per share.

How does BCE compare?

BCE reported third-quarter revenue of $6.18 billion, up 2.2%, helped by its US fibre Business Ziply Fiber. Adjusted EBITDA rose 0.9% to $2.79 billion, while adjusted EPS fell 6.3% to $0.74. BCE kept its quarterly dividend at $0.4375 per share, or $1.75 a year, after cutting it by about 56% in 2025. Postpaid mobile churn reached its lowest third-quarter level in four years.

Both companies have now reset dividends to fund debt reduction and new investment, including AI data centres. BCE's Yield is around 5.8%, while TELUS's yield on the new payout is around 6% at recent prices.

What would a Merger mean for BCE?

A Quebecor-TELUS combination would join Freedom Mobile and Videotron with TELUS, creating a company larger than Rogers or Bell by market value. That could mean a tougher competitor for BCE. However, experts said fewer national carriers could reduce competition and raise prices, which is why regulators are expected to look closely. Analysts have said the bid may struggle unless Quebecor is willing to sell Freedom Mobile.

What are the risks?

Key risks include regulatory rejection, a change in Quebecor's share price, TELUS seeking other alternatives, and continued pressure from slower population growth on subscriber additions. High debt levels at both TELUS and BCE limit flexibility, and price competition remains intense.

How has the market priced the two stocks?

TELUS shares have fallen more than 40% over the past year, as investors reacted to rising debt, the dividend cut, write-downs at TELUS Digital and TELUS Health, and slower customer growth. BCE also traded at multi-year lows after its own 2025 dividend reset. Quebecor, by contrast, outperformed its peers this year as Freedom Mobile gained subscribers with lower-priced plans.

The bid therefore lands when TELUS's market value, about $21.7 billion before the news, is close to Quebecor's own. That narrow gap is why a significant part of the payment is in Quebecor shares rather than cash.

What should investors watch next?

Investors should watch for the TELUS special committee's formal response, any improved or hostile offer from Quebecor, comments from the Competition Bureau and Industry Minister, and whether other bidders or partners emerge. Prime Minister Mark Carney declined to say whether Canada could accept losing a national carrier, telling reporters there are circumstances where fewer players can mean more competition. BCE's next update on its fourth-quarter results in February will show whether its fibre and AI investments are lifting growth.

For income-focused holders, the dividend question matters too. TELUS has said it will pause dividend growth while it reduces Leverage toward a target below three times by the end of 2028, while BCE investors should not expect dividend increases while the company focuses on lowering debt.

Conclusion

Quebecor's proposal puts a premium price on TELUS at a time when its shares have fallen more than 40% in a year, but the deal faces long odds on regulation and TELUS's own objections. For BCE, the immediate impact is strategic rather than financial. Investors comparing the two should weigh TELUS's takeover optionality against BCE's steadier revenue growth and dividend.